Thoughts on “Logan”

*I shall attempt a no spoilers post*

I recently went and saw the movie “Logan” which is the last film in the Marvel film series about the X-Men (or so it would seem).  I must say that as a person who has found just about every Marvel movie annoying since the original X-Men series, I was very pleased with this movie.  While all of the X-Men films, and Marvel films in general, have been the same special effects driven, generic movies, “Logan” had a a gritty, real world feel to it that made it far more engaging than the usual superhero movie.

That is because Logan (played by Hugh Jackman) is one of the few characters from the original films that is still a mutant and still has powers. However it becomes clear very early in the movie that his powers are waning, and he’s not the paragon of strength that “Wolverine” used to be. He’s looking old, his scars are showing, his eyesight is failing, he limps like a man whose worked too hard and is in his sixties, and his wondrous healing powers that had seen him through so much are disappearing. He also seems to be extremely depressed. After years of being something, he’s been reduced to a limo driver whose purpose is to drive around drunken idiots. He’s also taking care of his old friend, Professor Charles Xavier (played by Patrick Stewart) whose very old and suffering from Alzheimer. Logan has no choice but to watch as one of the most powerful minds in the world deteriorates into nothing. Professor X, on the other hand, is very aware that people are “just waiting for him to die.” Many older people experience this, which brings to Xavier a feeling of mortality as he realizes the restrictions of his brilliance brought on by old age.

The audience gets the feeling that Logan is about ready to give up. He’s carrying around an Adamantium bullet, the only thing that he knows that can definitely kill him. He’s realized that most of the purpose in his life has gone away, and he is ready to die. When he meets the little girl Laura, who has powers just like him, his will to live is renewed as he cannot help but love the child who becomes more than a little special to him.

Logan is a very interesting character to study, especially as he progresses through the series. When we first meet Logan, he is, indeed, a cage fighter in Canada, running away from a past he can’t remember and trying to avoid all human contact. This is probably because he’s trying to avoid getting hurt. He is very aware that if you care about anything, losing it means the potential for emotional pain. While he presents himself as a character with a massive chip on his shoulder who cares for no one, that doesn’t seem to be the case at all. In fact, he may be a loner, but he also has a big heart that is easily shattered by loss and pain. Throughout the series there are several deaths and un-requited love stories that he goes through.

What Logan’s attitude boils down to in the end is fear of loss, fear of pain, and possibly just a desire to not have to deal with that anymore. By the time we reach the Logan story, he has to be almost three hundred years old. In that span of time, one can be witness to more human tragedy than anyone should ever suffer. Some part of him probably longs for mortality, the release of death means the release from pain, which is probably why he carries that bullet around with him.

As Logan goes through the story, he realizes that he doesn’t have to kill himself. With his failing powers, he’s staring down mortality. And he realizes the limits of his strength just as any normal human would. The audience can tell that this brings him both relief and fear. But there’s one last thing he has to do. That he has to finish. And finish it he will, even if it ends him.

The movie “Logan” is all about endings. In some ways it is also about beginnings. There is the classic theme of passing the torch from one generation to the next. This is a theme that is as old as story telling as the old hero passes his sword to his child so that the child may carry on when he can no longer. It is also a story about how even heroes all fallible. Logan, who was once invincible, is no longer what he used to be. The mask of the hero is lifted to reveal a mere mortal. It is also about facing down fear, whether it be the fear of taking the risk and loving someone, or the fear of mortal limitations. All in all, it is perhaps the best film in the series.

Just like Deadpool, this movie is not really appropriate for children as it has it’s share of swearing and stabbing people through the head. However the violence in this movie is not a bad thing. It actually contributes to the story and the character as Logan, the Clint Eastwood cowboy type, carves his way to a difficult victory. In some ways it is like watching an old Western movie like The Good, The Bad and The Ugly, or a Chinese Kung-Fu film like The Blood of the Dragon where the hero doesn’t even fall down to die. Which in some ways kind of makes it a guy movie, but just about any X-Men fan, or action movie fan and sit and enjoy it. In fact it’s kind of nice that heralds back to that old action movie feel. The tone is both modern and nostalgic for those who have always loved action movies.

Thank you for reading! I hope you enjoyed it.

Scenes from Harold Godwinson

Hello and thank you for reading. I have finally finished my screenplay, Harold Godwinson, and I thought I would share a few scenes with my lovely followers and people I thought might be interested. They are chronologically in order, but there are, of course, scenes that come before and after each of these. I will go ahead and give a little explanation. Harold is the son of Godwin who was the Earl of Wessex in Britain. When Godwin dies, Harold takes up the title of Earl of Wessex as he is Godwin’s second son and heir. In January of 1066, Harold was crowned King Harold II of Britain. His fate is legend and I wanted to bring his story to the screen.His encounters with William Duke of Normandy would shape the history of Britain as the Anglo-Saxon kings were laid to rest, and the Anglo-Norman kings began to rise with William the Conqueror.

Note:Formatting is hard to do in a blog, but the script is formatted as it should be.

The scenes are as follows. The first scene is with Harold as he is just getting to know his consort, Edith of Essex. He had to meet, and fall in love with Edith fairly quickly because their relationship is an important cornerstone that runs throughout the story.  I thought it was a good scene to lead with because everyone loves a love scene.  Harold and Edith had an interesting love story that will conflict with what must be done when he become king and must marry a suitable wife.

Scene 2 is Harold’s first encounter with William of Normandy. This is a very important meeting, for what happens here will very much shape how the story ends and the primary conflict for Harold once he is king.

Scene 3 Harold’s brother Tostig is the 3rd most powerful man in Britain after King Edward and Harold who is still Earl of Wessex. He has abused his privilege and has taxed the people to the point of rebellion. He is called on his crimes and looks to Harold for help.

Scene 4 King Edward the Confessor dies. It is up to the Witan to determine who the next king of England will be.

CURIOUS ABOUT WHO MIGHT BE IN THIS MOVIE? THERE IS A VIDEO AT THE BOTTOM OF THE PAGE WITH CAST SUGGESTIONS. THANK YOU!!

FIRST SCENE

Int. Chamber of Edith – Night

Edith’s MAID is helping to comb Edith’s hair. Edith wears her long white night gown. There is a large fire in the fireplace, and the large bed sits over not far to the side of that. The door quietly opens, and Harold steps in.

Harold

My lady…

The Maid stops her task, but Edith is not interested in Harold.

Edith

Continue. Pay him no mind.

The Maid continues on. Harold comes around in front of the fireplace and gazes into the fire.

Harold

I know our Fathers arranged this for their own purposes, but I am not the villain you would like to think I am.

Edith

I do not think you a villain. It is not you that I am angry with.

Harold

In all truth, I wasn’t thrilled about it either. But now that I have met you, seen you…

Edith

So where does that leave us? Will you simply take what you want.

Harold

I am not that kind of man. I could never do you harm. But if you would have me, I would be yours.

Edith looked to her Maid.

Edith

You may leave me now.

Maid

(rises and bows)

Yes, my lady.

The Maid leaves Edith. Edith rises and walks over to where Harold stands. They are silhouetted in the firelight.

Edith

And would you have me?

Harold

If it would please you, I would give you whatever I could. Anything. I would have nothing else but you.

He embraces her and they kiss in the firelight.

Int. Chamber of Edith – Morning

Harold holds Edith close as they lay together. He watches her for a moment as she sleeps and then kisses her forehead.

Harold

I will never love anyone as I love you.

SECOND SCENE:

INT. GREAT HALL OF WILLIAM – Day

William sits in his chair and Harold comes into the hall. He walks to the front of the hall and bows to William. The hall is littered with the ADVISERS of William, and at least two PRIESTS stand near the dais.

Harold

My lord, there is something we must discuss.

William

I know what you wish to discuss. You wish to discuss leaving my realm. We shall do so now.

Harold

My thanks, my lord.

William

Of course. But there is something I wish you to do for me first.

Harold then notices an ornate table, standing not far from the dais. He makes nothing of it though, as it is covered with a ratty old cloth and does not seem to be important.

Harold

What is it you would ask of me, my lord?

William

First, I wish to announce your betrothal to my dear daughter, Agatha. She will be a great wife to you.

Harold is taken aback, but does not see a way in which he can refuse.

Harold

(shocked)

Of course, my lord…

William

And next, an oath of loyalty and kinship, so that we may be joined in faith and friendship. Swear!

Harold does not answer at first.

William

Do you not wish to be loyal to me? To swear friendship and loyalty? A true man of noble blood would do so.

Again, Harold cannot refuse.

Harold

I will swear my friendship and loyalty to you.

William

Very good. And one final oath. When Edward the Confessor dies, you will recommend me as king to the Witan. Swear!

A hesitation.

William

Come now! This is part of your loyalty to me.

Harold

But I cannot promise such a thing. Nor can Edward. It is the Witan that will make the final decision.

William

Perhaps you are not as honorable a man as I thought. Perhaps your whole family are dishonorable. If that be so, then maybe the life of your brother is not that important, seeing as he is probably dishonorable as well.

Harold

(Angry and mortified)

You threaten my brother?

William

A life without honor is no life at all, and therefore, has no right to be. Prove yourself, and I will know. Swear that you will tell the Witan to choose me.

Again, Harold cannot say no.

Harold

I swear that I will recommend you as King to the Witan, and I swear that you will be the next king.

William rises. He goes over to the covered table.

William

That is very good of you, Harold, Earl of Wessex. However, both you and I know that an oath made under duress is one that is not required of one to fulfill. So I thought you should see what is in this chest. Come here.

Harold walks over to the table and William, who pulls the cover off to expose holy relics and the bones of saints.

William

You have sworn in the presence of holy relics. These are the bones of saints. To go back on your word now would be reprehensible.

Harold

(beyond angry)

You filthy deceiver! You have lied to me! You have deceived me. Your cowardly tactics do not make the oath any more enforceable!

William

No, I’m sure you will see that they actually do. One cannot go against God. It is he who holds this oath and will see it fulfilled. Do your duty, sir, or pay the consequences.

Harold

(angered)

Fine, I will do my duty, but at least let me take my brother home.

William

I don’t know about that. I have become rather fond of him, and he is quite useful to have around. You may leave, but he must stay. Good day to you, Earl of Wessex. Safe journey home.

William waved his hand, and Harold was led out by Guards.

THIRD SCENE

INT. PALACE THRONEROOM – DAY

King Edward sits upon his throne with Queen Edith by his side. On either side of him, lords are seated upon benches. On the kings right hand side are the old Lords of the Witan, and on his left hand side are the Thanes, and the representatives from across the lands. Before him stands a very well dressed Tostig, Morcar, Edwin and Harold.

King Edward

Tostig Godwinson, Earl of Northumbria. You have been called here to face allegations of abuse of your power at the expense of the people. What say you, sir?

Tostig

Abuse of power? The expense of the people? That is just not so, your majesty. I have done all in my power to care for the people.

King Edward

And the unjust taxes?

Tostig

A rumor, your majesty.

Morcar

Then why did your people ask us to step in and investigate? I think the proof of the allegations are clear. Those are hardly practicle and modest garments, Earl of Northumbria.

Tostig

(angerly)

And who asked you to come into my realm and spy upon me?! You are the one who was out of line.

Edwin

I think not! When people are about to rebel, it is our place to try and quell the violence.

Tostig

(smugly)

My people would never rebel. They love me.

Morcar

Yes indeed. They plan to love you to death. They say if you ever return to that land, they will kill you.

Tostig

A mere lovers quarrel.

King Edward

We shall see. What do the representatives and Thanes have to say of this?

The Thanes and others of the region give their testimony. In the end, there is no doubt. Tostig is clearly guilty and everyone knows it. Harold gives his brother a sad look.

King Edward

The Thanes and others have given their testimony. Lord Lerith, what does the Witan have to say.

Lerith is an old man with short white hair and a long white beard. He is saddened by what he has to do.

Lerith

My king. The Witan finds that guilt is undeniable. The Earl of Northumbria, Tostig Godwinson, is guilty of the crimes of which he has been accused. You may now pass judgement.

King Edward

Very good. Tostig, Earl of Northumbria. You no longer have a right to that title, and it will be handed over to Morcar of Mercia, along with your estate and all other holdings. You are banished. Leave now.

Tostig

(beyond angry)

Your majesty. You cannot do that. You cannot do that!

King Edward

(Also beyond angry)

Are you telling me, your king, what I can and cannot do in my own court?! Leave now, and do not return, or the punishment will grow worse for you.

Tostig turns to Harold.

Tostig

(desperate)

Brother? Will you not help me?

Harold

(sad)

The king and the Witan have spoken. I am sorry, Tostig.

Tostig

(Insane with anger)

How could you betray me like this?! My brother has betrayed me!I stand betrayed by my people, my family. All of you!

King Edward

GET OUT!!!

The king’s exertion in yelling causes a coughing fit, and he is taken by his wife from the throne room. Tostig stares Harold down for another minute.

Tostig

Believe me, brother, I will be avenged. And you will suffer for your disloyalty!

Tostig storms from the hall, leaving a speechless Harold behind.

FOURTH SCENE

Int. Bed chamber of King Edward – late day

Edward lies upon his bed, Queen Edith stands beside it, holding his hand and weeping. When Harold arrives, she looks up at him and beckons for both he and Lerith. The rush over to her.

Queen Edith

Brother, the king is dying.

King Edward

(weakly)

Perhaps, but I am not dead yet. And seeing as that is the case, I should make my wishes known.

Harold

You wishes, your majesty?

King Edward

Yes. I appoint as the defenders of the realm…

He trails off as they all three wait in anticipation. Lerith cannot wait.

Lerith

Yes, my king?

King Edward

I appoint…My beloved wife, who I have so neglected over the years, and her beloved brother, Harold Godwinson, Earl of Wessex. You may put my preference forth, Lerith of the Witan.

Everyone is taken aback, especailly Harold. The king had appointed him. He knew the Witan might, but the king?

Harold

My god…

King Edward

Can you do this for your king, Harold?

Harold

Of course, my King. I would do this for king and country.

King Edward

Very good. Take care of my beloved wife. She will need you, and you her.

Harold

Yes, your majesty.

The king goes limp. King Edward The Confessor has died, and his wife dissolves in tears as Harold holds her. A few tears come to his eyes as well.

Harold

Lord Lerith. Gather the Witan. The king is dead.

Int. Palace Counsil Chamber – Night

In a dark chamber, lit by fires and torches, the men of the Witan gather. A group of Twenty men, all old and bearded sit in the room at a long table. The three most senior are Lerith, ANGAR, and KERRIK. The three men will control the proceedings.

Lerith

The king is dead, so it is now time for the Witan to make a decision on who the next king will be, since he left no heirs.

Angar

The closest relative to Edward is Edgar, who is now in Hungary.

Lerith

Edgar is a sickly child who has spent little time in our country. He is not a suitable leader for Englishmen.

Kerrik

Then perhaps Harald Hardrada of Norway. He is a strong man, and a good leader.

Lerith

He is still not an Englishman. He is a Norwegian King, and does not belong here. The people would see him as an invader, not a king. I wish to get this out of the way. Both King Edward and Harold Earl of Wessex have asked to put forward the name of William, Duke of Normandy.

Angar

Give that Norman bastard the throne of England? I would rather die than see that.

Lerith

Agreed.

Kerrik

But those are our only choices.

Lerith

I would like to suggest someone else. Harold Godwinson, Earl of Wessex and Brother-in-law to the king. He is an Englishman and a nobleman, and the people already love and respect him.

Angar

I agree with this. Harold would be a good choice. Kerrik?

Kerrik

I agree, lords Angar and Lerith.

Lerith

The name of Harold Godwinson, Earl of Wessex has been put forward. All in agreement with this, raise your right hand.

All of the men of the Witan raise their hands.

Lerith

It is decided. Harold Godwinson, Earl of Wessex will be crowned King Harold the second. Thank you, my lords. Our decision is good.

The men of the Witan agree by nodding and exiting the room. Lerith goes to tell Harold.

The Value of Fan Fiction, Fan Art, Fan Videos and Costumes

 

 

Hello all. Thought I would go ahead and post something because it is one of those things I am interested in.  It is often said by some that “fan projects” are not worth the time or effort. This is not true at all. “Fan projects” are more pivotal now than they ever have been. Why do I say this? Because engaging in fan activities such as writing fan fiction, doing fan videos and creating fan art are fostering the next generation of artists. Basically what I am saying is that, with these projects comes knowledge, practice in the art that you want to be involved in, and experience.

Lets start with fan fiction. Many authors will say that this is not the kind of thing that “real” writers engage in. That is not true. Even writers and film makers that are well respected have dabbled in borrowing, fan fiction and “ripping off”. Take Suzanne Collins who wrote “The Hunger Games”. It is quite clearly based, in some form off of the film “Battle Royale”, A Japanese film about a group of Japanese students who are forced to fight to the death in a contest where only one is meant to come out alive.

Then again, “Battle Royale” is much more interesting and amusing, because it is not a film made to be considered as “overly serious film”, it is a film that caters to the interest of many audiences, action fans, Japanese film fan, people who like the irony and strong social messages put forward by the film. But basically it is an “it is what it is film, and if you try to make it something more, you’ll merely disappoint yourself”. The Hunger Games” caters to it’s built in audience, and is therefore full of teen angst and characters that one only finds interesting if they are into that sort of movie. There’s nothing wrong with the films. For me, they are just not as entertaining as a film like “Battle Royale”. But still, it cannot be denied that the premise is basically the same and one is simply more entertaining that the other.

Let’s take a moment to look at “Star Wars” and George Lucas. George Lucas’s earliest movie was “THX1138”, a dystopian film about a very controlled society. Here we actually have Lucas who has borrowed from George Orwell, who’s books (that later became films) are basically the same story. People living in a controlled society. Then when it came time for “Star Wars”, George Lucas, who was a great fan of Akira Kurosawa, basically took the plot of Kurosawa’a film “The Hidden Fortress” and set it in space. The George Lucas ripped himself off and Created “Willow” which is the same story with little people and Val Kilmer. Then, as Honest Trailers pointed out, J.J. Abrams basically recycled the plot, except this time around, Luke was a young woman who didn’t whine or complain as much. And in fact, you could say that Collins ripped off both Lucas and Orwell…Haha…

Even a smutty book like “Fifty Shades of Grey” was borrowed from the plot of “Twilight”, which I have always found amusing. Anne Rice took the plot of “Sleeping Beauty” and filled it with smut. Also borrowing from other people is what remakes are, adaptations are, they are also why Marvel keeps regurgitating it’s superhero franchises.

So here’s the thing. If these people are allowed to borrow, adapt, rip off and do all these other sorts of things, why can’t we fans do so? Some writers will say that, “ah, fan fiction. That is no good because you’re just taking someone else’s story and doing things with it.” Well yeah! That’s what art is all about. Copying and borrowing from the masters in order to gain competence. Even Da Vinci and Michelangelo started, probably from copying some of their art, or borrowing it from the person that they learned from. Everyone learns something. The difference is how quickly you can pick it up.

Also they say, “oh you don’t get good feedback on fan fiction”. Not true at all. If you are a good writer, people will know it and know how to respond to your writing, regardless of what it is based off of. There is a difference in writing styles and motives in fan fiction. One is for the writer who someday wants to write. The other is for people who use it for some kind of odd wish fulfillment, which shouldn’t be in the same caliber. However, I have gotten a lot of good feedback from writing fan fics. People seem to like what I write and know what kind of writer I am, and therefore, they ask questions, point out plot holes, make comments on my having too much exposition, all kinds of useful comments. So one cannot claim that they do not get good feed back. If you are a good writer who is working to morph a good narrative, readers will know it.

Some fan videos are wonderful, and I enjoy watching them. They can be funny, touching, interesting visually, and just plain emotional. So here the thing. What you are looking at are the writers, comedians, film editors, and producers/directors of the future. If you can make a good fan video that people like, then chances are you want to work in film. The fact that you are working with someone elses content, just as long as you make it clear that you are playing with someone elses baby, and you’re not slapping your name on it saying, “this is mine”, I don’t see a problem with it. When I edit photos, people know they are not mine. Nor do I claim them as mine. They belong to someone else, and I try to make that as clear as possible when I give credits to people. So we should not demonize people for stealing when all they are doing is borrowing. If they have the footage, chances are they own the original, and most people still like to buy the DVD. Personally I don’t like downloads of anything, whether it’s film or music or game content. I want something I can hold, that is mine. So I still buy DVDs and things. I love things like commentary and interviews and extras, so I buy the damn movie! It isn’t mine. I claim nothing because I cannot. All I do is what most other artists do is borrow and take what I can from a given plot and work with it. Here are a couple of videos from Sweetladybat that I just love.

Fan art is also a very useful teaching tool. Again, learning from the masters. Also fan costumes. If you go to conventions, you will see thousands of costumes that people have worked numerous hours on, sometimes just to wear to one event. What you have here is artists in the making and future costume designers. You may have the next Edith Head amongst their numbers. Or even a Donatella Versace is you think about it. why would the film industry and fashion industry not take advantage of these people and their art?

There are so many fandoms out there, and there are so many people who want to be a part of them. And if you do not foster the talent of the next Shakespeare, or the next Da Vinci, or the next Edith Head, the industry will be missing out on some great and awesome talent.

Thank you for reading, I greatly appreciate it!! Shara

Recent Issues In Hollywood. You know, the diversity thing and the rehashing…

Hello ladies and gents!! Decided to do a little something different this time around!! I have been checking out entertainment and film news lately, and there are some interesting things going on. First of all, Jennifer Lawrence pointed out that when the Sony emails came out, she noticed she was not being paid as much as her male counterparts. Also, Viola Davis recently pointed out that people of color were not offered as many opportunities as their Caucasian counterparts. Also there was the bit where Matt Damon said on his show, “Project Green Light” that diversity behind the camera was not as important as diversity in front of it.

Jennifer Lawrence makes an interesting point when she said that she was not paid as much as the male actors in her films, but in some ways, that has been the way that it has always been. Males have generally made more money than females throughout history regardless of what profession they are in. Why is that? I could not say for sure, but it sort of reeks of some sort of superiority thing, and it is definitely a control thing. Consider a scenario where everybody made the same amount of money for doing the same job. This would be ideal, and would make everyone equal. However, the world is not ideal. Not that that ideal situation cannot be achieved. It certainly can. The problem is, we’re not there yet in any facet of society. While Americans claim that there is equality between men and women, it is not necessarily true. If it were true, then we would be in that ideal zone. So that does not exist yet. While women currently have some amount of respect in Hollywood, because they do their jobs and do them well, that does not make them equal to their male co-star. If they were, everybody would be making the same kind of money. Ms. Lawrence is also right when she says that when you ask why you are not getting what you want or need, people tend to call a person difficult. It is especially easy to call a woman difficult. I even tweeted recently to Elijah Wood that, “it is easy to call a woman difficult merely because you don’t want to deal with them”. Again, true and not true. While there are some women who genuinely want to do things in order to better their situation, there are those who are in fact difficult. So there is a difference between that woman who wants to make things better and the woman who is truly difficult and a pain. And certainly there are male actors who are difficult as well. It is not a solely female issue. There are many people in the film industry that are just plain hard to work with. It is whether or not the reputation is true to the person that is the issue. Some people are difficult, others they want you to think are difficult.

Diversity is an interesting watch-word these days. Viola Davis says more people of color, Matt Damon says not necessarily. She’s right, he’s wrong. We need people of color in front of the camera, behind the camera, writing, directing, doing costumes, music, everything! Not on every film, but it is best to make sure that both cast and crew are as diverse as possible. Having more diverse people means having more creativity, ideas, direction, whatever. Not only that, but an Asian person, say a Chinese person, or a Korean person, or a Japanese person, Malaysian person, or what have you, are going to know more about Korean, Chinese, Japanese culture than a Caucasian person who is trying to write for them. They know their culture better than a person from outside of it. This is also true for Hispanic people, African American people, or people of African descent, whoever the cultural person is. So we need those writers and directors and producers. They will make the project more authentic. (one thing that kind of offended me was the fact that they chose Scarlett Johannsen to be the lead in “Ghost In The Shell”. Any hard core anime fan has seen it a million times, any science fiction fan has seen it a couple of times, and then there are people who just love good Japanese animation who loved it too. This was the perfect opportunity to use a Japanese actress, but they decided to go with a woman who was not Japanese. This made me incredibly sad…)

Last thing that has been bothering me lately. Recently, Hugh Jackman was in a movie called “Pan”. It sounds to me like it didn’t go very well, or at least it was not as great of a success as people expected it to be. What is the reason for this? It is not the fault of the actors, as I am sure that they all did the best they could. It was perhaps because of the fact that the story of Peter Pan has been told a million times in a million ways. And while each method of telling the story might be slightly different, it’s still the same story. Very often people get bored when they are offered the same thing over and over again (what’s the definition of insanity again?). If it is a story people have heard over and over again, they are going to lose interest. Batman=done to death, Marvel=also done to death, films about zombies=done to death!! Where’s all the great stuff that people used to make? The quirky science fantasy stuff and the action flicks that weren’t sequels, and the comedies that didn’t run off of bad sex jokes? All gone. Traded for rehashing, endless sequels, and a whole bunch of other stuff that nobody asked for. I will admit, there are a few dramas that I am anxious to see, and I am going to go and see “Star Wars” at least once (I hope I am not disappointed). Somehow it disappoints me that studios aren’t willing to take risks anymore. They want guaranteed hits as opposed to the films that may merely break even. What that does though is it leaves the little guy, passionate film makers who have the drive but not the resources, out in the cold. I know many fine young film makers who are starting out on fan films, and webseries, and other ambitious projects who would love nothing better than to be given a chance to make a film with the resources that the production companies and studios spend on the big guys. If we don’t help them out, then there are so many diverse stories that will never be told. Many of the people I know that are working on film projects are young people of color, and they deserve a chance. So lets finish with the rehashing and give these guys a chance!!

Thank you for reading this post. I know it is slightly long winded and perhaps a bit dour, but it was an opinion I just had to get out. I appreciate your readership!! If you like what you see, or you have an opinion, please comment, follow or like. This is my opinion, and I thank you for giving it a read!! Cheers and many thanks!!

Shara

Amusing Things You’ll see in “The Lord Of the Rings” Films!

Hello again! I am back with one of my “Amusing Things” entries! This one is on “The Lord of the Rings Trilogy” because I simply could not resist. Tolkien’s books have been a constant companion to me since the fifth grade, and I still enjoy reading them, and my journeys to Middle Earth when I play “The Lord of the Rings Online”. Anyway, I am a long time fan of the films as well. They are very good adaptations, and I enjoy them when I watch them.

Featuring Elijah Wood, Sean Astin, Ian McKellen, Viggo Mortensen, Orlando Bloom, John Rhys-Davies, Billy Boyd, Dominic Monaghan, Sean Bean, Cate Blanchett, Miranda Otto, David Wenham, Karl Urban, John Noble, Christopher Lee, Brad Dourif, Andy Serkis, Liv Tyler, Karl Urban and so many more. Directed by Peter Jackson and written by Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens and Stephen Sinclair, produced through New Line Cinema, Wingnut Films, and The Saul Zaentz Company. Lastly, but not leastly, for my beloved J.R.R. Tolkien. I loved your books, these are good films.

Of course this is a joke blog, so most of what you will see here are jokes, but there are a few serious ones as well. So please have a look and enjoy!! Thank you for reading, and cheers!!

Lets kick this off with New Zealand: Fantasy land Edition!!

Gandalf’s coming…Must be bad news.

Elijah Wood as Frodo and Ian McKellen as Gandalf.

Elijah Wood as Frodo and Ian McKellen as Gandalf.

Blessed they are.

Sean Astin as Sam.

Sean Astin as Sam.

Bilbo wants to finish his book!

Ian Holm as Bilbo.

Ian Holm as Bilbo.

But he has a few things to say to his relations before he goes.

Ian Holm as Bilbo.

Ian Holm as Bilbo.

And there are these miscreants hanging around.

Billy Boyd as Pippin and Dominic Monaghan as Merry.

Billy Boyd as Pippin and Dominic Monaghan as Merry.

Don’t worry though Frodo. It’s the Lone Ranger to the rescue!

Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn.

Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn.

Ponies! The Volkswagen bugs of Middle Earth!

Bill the Pony...Yay...

Bill the Pony…Yay…

Remember the killer meme? Even Boromir is sick of this shit!

Sean Bean as Boromir.

Sean Bean as Boromir.

Totally giving up your motivation!

Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn and Liv Tyler as Arwen.

Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn and Liv Tyler as Arwen.

Not knowing anything about anything and trying to get out of everything.

Viggo Mortensen, Ian McKellen, Orlando Bloom, Sean Bean, John Rhys-Davies, Billy Boyd, Dominic Monaghan, Elijah Wood and Sean Astin.

Viggo Mortensen, Ian McKellen, Orlando Bloom, Sean Bean, John Rhys-Davies, Billy Boyd, Dominic Monaghan, Elijah Wood and Sean Astin.

Slightly senile Gandalf.

Ian McKellen as Gandalf.

Ian McKellen as Gandalf.

Galadriel, who doesn’t even know what’s in her own magic mirror.

Cate Blanchett as Galadriel and Elijah Wood as Frodo.

Cate Blanchett as Galadriel and Elijah Wood as Frodo.

Saruman, who screwed everyone over!

Christopher Lee as Saruman and Ian McKellen as Gandalf.

Christopher Lee as Saruman and Ian McKellen as Gandalf.

Sean Bean can’t catch a break…

Sean Bean as Boromir.

Sean Bean as Boromir.

Three Hunters head into Rohan.

Orlando Bloom, Viggo Mortensen, John Rhys-Davies.

Orlando Bloom, Viggo Mortensen, John Rhys-Davies.

Unfortunately they run into a rogue doctor.

Karl Urban as Eomer.

Karl Urban as Eomer.

His uncle is being controlled by Rasputin.

Christopher Lee as Saruman, Brad Dourif as Grima and Miranda Otto as Eowyn.

Christopher Lee as Saruman, Brad Dourif as Grima and Miranda Otto as Eowyn.

But that’s okay, because Aragorn comes to his sister’s aid. He just doesn’t want her.

Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn and Miranda Otto as Eowyn.

Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn and Miranda Otto as Eowyn.

Gandalf rents a Ford Mustang!

Shadowfax.

Shadowfax.

But out in the fields, they run into the junkers of Middle Earth!

Orc on a warg.

Orc on a warg.

Merry and Pippin were almost eaten by wicked orcs!! Thankfully this happened.

Uruk-Hai played by Sala Baker.

Uruk-Hai played by Sala Baker.

And in the forest, this is happening!

John Rhys-Davies as Treebeard, Billy Boyd and Dominic Monaghan.

John Rhys-Davies as Treebeard, Billy Boyd and Dominic Monaghan.

Frodo and Sam are making their way toward Mordor. And Intestinal distress.

Sean Astin as Sam and Elijah Wood as Frodo.

Sean Astin as Sam and Elijah Wood as Frodo.

They encounter a strange creature played by Andy Serkis!!

Andy Serkis as Gollum.

Andy Serkis as Gollum.

The dipshit has no idea what taters are.

Sean Astin as Sam and Andy Serkis as Gollum.

Sean Astin as Sam and Andy Serkis as Gollum.

Theoden comes out of his stupor.

Ian McKellen as Gandalf and Bernard Hill as Theoden.

Ian McKellen as Gandalf and Bernard Hill as Theoden.

Only to have to face this!!

Bernard Hill as Theoden and Bruce Hopkins as Gamling. and a snarky orc.

Bernard Hill as Theoden and Bruce Hopkins as Gamling. and a snarky orc.

Tolkiens Thermopylae.

Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn.

Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn.

Where we get to meet Elvish Shawn White.

Orlando Bloom as Legolas.

Orlando Bloom as Legolas.

Frodo says hello to an old friend!!

Elijah Wood and Lawrence Makoare as Witch King.

Elijah Wood and Lawrence Makoare as Witch King.

Frodo and Sam face Aragog!

Shelob.

Shelob.

Sorry crazy freakshow arachnid.

Denethor tells Faramir he loves him!

John Noble as Denethor and David Wenham as Faramir.

John Noble as Denethor and David Wenham as Faramir.

Pippin is pissed because he has to deal with an idiot.

Billy Boyd as Pippin, John Noble as Denethor.

Billy Boyd as Pippin, John Noble as Denethor.

It’s okay though. There’s an awesome woman there to save the day!

Miranda Otto as Eowyn and Lawrence Makoare as the Witch king.

Miranda Otto as Eowyn and Lawrence Makoare as the Witch king.

And evening up the odds.

Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn.

Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn.

But there are totally giant elephant things out there, dude!!!

Mumakil.

Mumakil.

Gollum suffers from the effects of his addiction!

Andy Serkis as Gollum.

Andy Serkis as Gollum.

Oh my…

Sam and Frodo say farewell.

Sean Astin and Elijah Wood.

Sean Astin and Elijah Wood.

But Aragorn makes everybody happy again!

Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn.

Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn.

Sauron suffers badly for his crimes.

The Eye of Sauron.

The Eye of Sauron.

And finally, the damn Eagles arrive.

Ian McKellen as Gandalf and Elijah Wood as Frodo, as well as Sean Astin as Sam.

Ian McKellen as Gandalf and Elijah Wood as Frodo, as well as Sean Astin as Sam.

Faramir decides he loves somebody…Aw…

David Wenham as Faramir and Miranda Otto as Eowyn.

David Wenham as Faramir and Miranda Otto as Eowyn.

Blessed they are.

Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn.

Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn.

Song for Aragorn.

It only takes a lifetime.

Viggo Mortensen and Liv Tyler as Arwen.

Viggo Mortensen and Liv Tyler as Arwen.

The hobbits return to the Shire and Sam gets his happily ever after.

Sean Astin as Sam and Sarah McLeod as Rosie.

Sean Astin as Sam and Sarah McLeod as Rosie.

Being pruny!!

Ian Holm as Bilbo.

Ian Holm as Bilbo.

Frodo says goodbye to his Sam.

Elijah Wood as Frodo and Sean Astin as Sam.

Elijah Wood as Frodo and Sean Astin as Sam.

Namarie…

Elijah Wood as Frodo.

Elijah Wood as Frodo.

Blessed they are.

Sailing into the West.

Sailing into the West.

Sam returns home.

Sean Astin as Sam and Sarah McLeod as Rosie. Also Ali Astin as Elenor and Maisy McLeod-Riera as Baby Gamgee (presumably Frodo...haha.)

Sean Astin as Sam and Sarah McLeod as Rosie. Also Ali Astin as Elenor and Maisy McLeod-Riera as Baby Gamgee (presumably Frodo…haha.)

Much thanks and love to Peter Jackson, for making these films!!

Peter Jackson.

Peter Jackson.

Well that’s it! I will probably be back sometime to do some citation, but for now, I am going to go ahead and release it into the wild. If you like it, leave me a comment or something!! I greatly appreciate you all reading. Anyway, Star Wars and Supernatural coming up. Have a preference? Tell me about it!! Thank you so much!! I hope you enjoyed this and will be back for the next!!

Amusing things that you will see in The Hobbit.

Hello all!! This is the second post in the “Amusing Things Collection”. Thank you so much for reading my last Post on “The Almighty Johnsons”, I very much appreciate it! Anyway, I must say that I quite enjoyed the Hobbit films, as they were good adaptations of something that is hard to adapt. Tolkien is notoriously hard to adapt because his world is greater and more complex than can be conveyed in film. So it was wonderful for an adaptation of a Tolkien work. Directed by Peter Jackson, and written by Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens and, Guillermo Del Toro and featuring Ian McKellen, Martin Freeman, Cate Blanchett, Aidan Turner, Graham McTavish, Dean O’Gorman, Lee Pace, Evangeline Lilly, Orlando Bloom, Stephen Hunter, James Nesbitt, Jed Brophy, Adam Brown, Benedict Cumberbatch, Ian Holm, and so many others. Brought to you, of course, by New Line Cinema, MGM, Wingnut Films and 3Foot7. I did not get to do as many of these as I may have wanted, so this may be part one. Again, a bunch of jokes and one liners about “The Hobbit” series. Thank you all, I hope you find at least some of these funny!!

Being attracted to shiny objects.

The Arkenstone.

The Arkenstone.

That “Holy crap!!!” moment when you see a dragon.

Richard Armitage as Thorin.

Richard Armitage as Thorin.

Releasing you reptiles into the wild when they get too big for you to handle.

Benedict Cumberbatch as Smaug.

Benedict Cumberbatch as Smaug.

Dwarves who are at your service.

Aidan Turner, Dean O'Gorman and Martin Freeman.

Aidan Turner, Dean O’Gorman and Martin Freeman.

Being hot dwarves.

Richard Armitage, Dean O'Gorman and Aidan Turner.

Richard Armitage, Dean O’Gorman and Aidan Turner.

Yeah, I think that the fan girls are totally after you, but me and Sing are here to rescue you.

Stephen Chow as Sing in Kung-Fu Hustle (2004).

Stephen Chow as Sing in Kung-Fu Hustle (2004).

Obesity!

Stephen Hunter as Bombur and the Great Goblin channeling Eric Cartman.

Stephen Hunter as Bombur and the Great Goblin channeling Eric Cartman.

A Japanese school girl. (yeah I totally had to go there)

Aidan Turner and Martin Freeman.

Aidan Turner and Martin Freeman.

The Three Stooges!

Martin Freeman and Trolls.

Martin Freeman and Trolls.

What happens to those big blue people from Avatar when you leave them in the dark too long…And do terrible things to them.

Azog the Defiler played by Manu Bennett and CGI.

Azog the Defiler played by Manu Bennett and CGI.

Schizophrenia… (sorry if this is offensive. Couldn’t help myself.)

Gollum played by Andy Serkis.

Gollum played by Andy Serkis.

Unabashed hair porn.

Richard Armitage playing Thorin and Jed Brophy playing Nori.

Richard Armitage playing Thorin and Jed Brophy playing Nori.

One of the most annoying tropes in fantasy. (arachnophobia…  :P)

Martin Freeman as Bilbo and CGI spiders.

Martin Freeman as Bilbo and CGI spiders.

The worst pick-up line in the history of Middle Earth. (No seriously, Tolkien was rolling in his grave)

Aidan Turner, Evangeline Lilly, Dean O'Gorman and Orlando Bloom.

Aidan Turner, Evangeline Lilly, Dean O’Gorman and Orlando Bloom.

Doing time.

Aidan Turner as Kili.

Aidan Turner as Kili.

Captain not appearing in this book.

Evangeline Lilly as Tauriel.

Evangeline Lilly as Tauriel.

Being short in general.

The Company of Thorin Oakenshield, Aidan Turner, Dean O'Gorman, Martin Freeman, Graham McTavish, Ken Stott, William Kircher, James Nesbitt, Stephen Hunter, John Callen, Peter Hambleton, Jed Brophy, Mark Hadlow, and Adam Brown.

The Company of Thorin Oakenshield, Aidan Turner, Dean O’Gorman, Martin Freeman, Graham McTavish, Ken Stott, William Kircher, James Nesbitt, Stephen Hunter, John Callen, Peter Hambleton, Jed Brophy, Mark Hadlow, and Adam Brown.

Being an expert at hurling insults.

Richard Armitage, Aidan Turner and Lee Pace as Thranduil.

Richard Armitage, Aidan Turner and Lee Pace as Thranduil.

Showing off your nuts.

Aidan Turner as Kili.

Aidan Turner as Kili.

Weird ass crap that you find in fan fiction like:

Thilbo Bagginshield!

Richard Armitage as Thorin and Martin Freeman as Bilbo.

Richard Armitage as Thorin and Martin Freeman as Bilbo.

Durincest!!

Dean O'Gorman and Aidan Turner as Fili and Kili.

Dean O’Gorman and Aidan Turner as Fili and Kili.

Throninduil!!

Richard Armitage and Lee Pace.

Richard Armitage and Lee Pace.

and many many other weird things…

Stuff that leads to this (though it’s not really a bad thing)!!

Aidan Turner in the BBC show

Aidan Turner in the BBC show “Poldark” Scything and asking the fundamental question.

And stuff that leads to this.

Anders Johnson/Bragi played by Dean O'Gorman

Anders Johnson/Bragi played by Dean O’Gorman

Realizing what’s really important.

Richard Armitage as Thorin and Aidan Turner as Kili.

Richard Armitage as Thorin and Aidan Turner as Kili.

Never was there a tale of more woe…

Evangeline Lilly and Aidan Turner.

Evangeline Lilly and Aidan Turner.

All well that ends well…

Ian McKellen as Gandalf.

Ian McKellen as Gandalf.

Alright ladies and gents, that’s all for now. Relevant song links below. Thank you for reading!! I hope to hear from you!! Thank you so much to the lovely talent in the films, I appreciate what you have created.

Adventures that make one late to dinner…

Ridiculous dwarves!!

Thranduil will teach you a lesson!

Sadness?

Hope remains.

The Promised Land.

Thank you for reading and cheers!!

Loyalty and Justice In Samurai film first chapters

Hello all, this is the first five sections of a book I am trying to get published. It is about Samurai films and loyalty and justice within them, and cover such films as Gohatto, Bunraku and the original 47 Ronin film. Anyway, feel free to look it over and comment, if you feel like it. And this is only the first few sections, so this is not the whole thing, so let me know what you think. Cheers!!

Examining Loyalty and Justice in Samurai Film

By Shara Maude

First 4000 words

Film Genre
Samurai film comes under the heading of Jidai-geki film, which basically means a film based before the Meiji Restoration, or a film involving samurai. Galloway points out two genres within Jidai-geki that are in fact very important. Sengoku-jidai is based during the Sengoku period, better known as “the Warring States period”1, which was a violent time within Japan where multiple factions were fighting each other for supremacy. A good example of a Sengoku-jidai film would be The Hidden Fortress, which was set in this era and shows the malice between states as the Princess’s clan has been completely destroyed by the neighboring state.
The other genre is the Tokugawa-jidai, or Edo-jidai, a film set in the Tokugawa or Edo period.2 A good example of a film from this period would be Sanjro, or Chushingura (The 47 Ronin)3, even though these films deal with corrupt officials, they are set in a time of relative peace where states very seldom went to war with each other. It is also a time when the act of revenge was not allowed, which will mean ruin for the 47 Ronin when the time comes.
Within these genres there are also sub-genres of film. Desser describes several samurai film genres, starting with The Nostalgic Samurai Drama4 a good example of a nostalgic film being The Twilight Samurai, being more about the story than the action. Another genre Desser describes is the Zen Fighters5 genre that pits men of faith against enemies. A good example would be Princess Mononoke, and the warrior monk Gigo. Sanjuro could probably be considered a Zen warrior film as well. Finally there is The Sword Film6 also known as Chambara. Since every film for this project involves some kind of swordsman, it is difficult to find a film among them that is not Chambara. The Twilight Samurai would probably not be considered Chambara. Since the only real action in this film is in the last 20 minutes, Chushingura (The 47 Ronin) would not be Chambara, but would be considered drama along with Twilight. Also Gohatto is more about drama than action, so it also would be thought of as Nostalgic and not Chambara.
Some of these films are difficult to fit into a time category as well. Princess Mononoke appears to take place during the Sengoku period, but the guns and the mention of “Lord Asano” in the film makes me think otherwise, as Asano is a name that does not appear until late in the Sengoku period and early in the Tokugawa period. I say this because in Chushingura (The 47 Ronin), there is Lord Asano, a young man readying himself to meet the Shogun. The Last Samurai7 actually takes place during the Meiji Restoration after the Shogunate has been dissolved. Would this be considered to be a Tokugawa-jidai film? Bunraku8 is not a period film at all, but features a samurai in a post apocalyptic world where he is forced to team up with a cowboy to find a medallion and revenge. This being the case, the only genre it can really fit under is Chambara. Then it is not hard to place it in a time period as it is obviously a modern film, but it does complicate genre a bit.

Bunraku—Justice Through Revenge
Bunraku9 is an interesting film to talk about because it is not a conventional samurai film. The film, set in a post-apocalyptic world, in a land ruled by a ruthless gang leader. Two strange visitors come to his city one day, a lonely Drifter and a samurai names Yoshi. Together they must bring down this evil gang leader before he takes over the world. Woody Harrelson who plays the bartender says it best, “a cowboy in a world without guns and a samurai with no sword team up to fight a common evil.”10 Yoshi the samurai11 does not originally come to the land of Nicola The Woodcutter for revenge. He has come on behalf of his dead father who wants him to retrieve a family heirloom.
This is all well and good until he runs into trouble with Nicola’s gang. When the vicious Killer Number 2 kills his uncle and kidnaps his cousin, it very much turns into a story of revenge. Now Yoshi must fight and defeat Killer Number 2 if he is going to go any further. This follows the classic outline of Desser’s outline for the sword film12. There is a scene of violence, Nicola’s men defeating another faction. The hero is identified when we see Yoshi on the train. The heroes circumstance is that he has come to reclaim his families heirloom. The victim is both the city, and Yoshi’s uncle and cousin, but actually we meet both the villain, Nicola the Woodcutter and the henchman, Killer Number 2, very early in the film. Yoshi does not actually meet Killer Number 2 until late in the film, but the audience is introduced to him early, so 2 knows about Yoshi, but Yoshi has never met 2. This leaves Yoshi at a disadvantage. There is the interlude, the slaughterfest and the spectacular duel where Yoshi helps eliminate Nicola’s army and his other killers. Then Yoshi kills Killer Number 2, the evil henchmen, bringing the story of the samurai character full circle. He does not get to kill Nicola though, as that is part of the Drifters story, but he does retrieve his cousin, the heirloom and avenge his uncle, which means the sword film story arch has come to a successful end for our samurai.
While Bunraku may be an unconventional samurai film, it follows the basic story arch of what a samurai film is. Yoshi also is not the main character in the story, but his story does end with a relatively happy ending, as Asian cinema goes. He and the Drifter walk off into the sunset, leaving to go on other adventures. The narrator in the film tells the audience, “revenge is an act of style”, and this film is very full of style.
This film can be odd to watch because it is an action film and not a traditional samurai film. It is also completely shot on sets in the studio, no kinds of exterior shots whatsoever. The film has a very distinct look to it, and while interesting, the art effects can be quite dizzying at times. It is a film that was very clearly made with the action fans interest in mind. This is the first action film written and directed by Guy Moshe who had only done shorts before. As a first attempt at a feature length action film it is not a bad film. It is merely a different style of film, and was made with cost very much in mind. Not that that is a bad thing, as many low budget films have done amazingly well. It is quite clear however that this was made for a Western audience and for lovers of samurai and martial arts films in general. The samurai values and honor are very alive in the character Yoshi though. As a samurai in a modern film, he is an interesting representation, and the fact that he is going on this mission to find something for his dead father means that he is placing family honor very much before his own well-being.

Chushingura (The 47 Ronin)–Extreme Loyalty and Justice through Revenge
Chushingura (The 47 Ronin)13 is an interesting film to watch because it is based on true events. There really were forty-seven men who sought vengeance for their lord. Young Lord Asano is chosen to receive the Shogun for a visit. Sadly is is tricked by a trick from Lord Kira into drawing his sword within the Shogun’s castle. It all begins with Lord Kira feeling he is being slighted because Asano fails to give him a satisfactory bribe.
Asano’s celebrated refusal to bribe Lord Kira because such action is forbidden by the Kemmu Shikimoku, the legal code established by the Muromachi shogunate in 1336, becomes more an act of anachronistic stubbornness than existential revolt against Tokugawa policy in 1701.14
Basically bribery was expected at this time, and young lords who refused to give into such things were praised by some for their honest, but the person expressing the bribe feels slighted, and will seek out their own revenge, so to say. In this case, Kira refuses to tell Asano how he should receive the Shogun, as there are traditional behaviors and customs that need to be met and Asano does not know what they are, and it is Kira’s job to tell Asano what to do.
Kira seems to be a very vindictive man, as he refuses to tell Asano anything, and insults Asano by saying that he is no better than a commoner15, which is considered a great insult to even a young lord. He draws his sword and his fate is sealed. He must commit seppuku or be executed for his crimes, which is a great dishonor. “…everything leading up to Lord Asano’s seppuku—is fully detailed and consumes a major portion of the narrative. Certainly Asano’s prideful behavior up to his interrogation and the Shogun’s clipped comment (“the rules are clear. Keep to the rules.”) serve as ironic undertone.”16 It is a rather over dramatized moment leading up to Asano’s seppuku and the seppuku itself17. This is because Asano is a young man who made a minor lapse in judgment and decided to act upon an insult rather than keeping his temper.
This is where the story of the 47 ronin really begins. Asano is dead, but his men want to avenge what they think is an injustice toward their lord. Because of Asano’s death, they all become masterless samurai, and must find other means of living. Then again, that is part of the plot, to make the Shogunate believe that they have accepted the death of their lord and have moved on as ronin. However, at one point in the film, Oishi, the chamberlain tells one of his men who is about to die by seppuku that, “we are going to deceive the shogunate.” This means that they will take on roles that will make them seem like they are no threat to Kira, but Kira still fears them.
The 47 ronin did exactly as Oishi said they would. The deceived the Shogunate and took their revenge upon Kira, the man responsible for their lords death. Turnbull says,
What is extraordinary about the story is the fantastic lengths to which they went in order to make Kira think that they had all split up, had no communication with each other, and had all abandoned the profession of samurai. Their leader, Oishi Yoshio, even divorced his wife, and kept the facade of drunken, dissolute pleasure—seeking. One snowy night in December 1702 the ronin, dressed in homemade armor, struck at Kira’s mansion in Edo….Kira Yoshinaka was eventually found hiding in an outhouse.18
In the end, the samurai got their revenge, but it was bittersweet. The act of revenge was actually forbidden at the time, and all forty-seven men, though they had survived, had broken the law. The only way for them to repent for this sin, was for all of them to commit seppuku. Victory and revenge sometime come with a heavy price.
The fact that this was based off of a true story is interesting. While most Western audiences might not be familiar with the story, Japanese audiences certainly are. In a way, this could be considered a historical text because it deals with an actual historical event. This film more than any of the others, is a real story about people that actually existed. Not only that, but this film stays very close to the actual events that took place, as it showed Oishi as the drunkard, and in the end, the fear of Kira as he is found shivering in the outhouse.
There is also the fact that all the men who participated in the raid on Kira’s mansion had to kill themselves. A Western audience might not see the sensibility in this action, but a Japanese audience knows that these men have broken the rules of the Shogun who has forbidden revenge killing. Again, the question would be “why would they do it then?” The answer is simple to some audiences. They had total commitment to the lord they served and loved. It made sense to these men to continue to serve their lord even well after his death. This dedication to one’s lord was what made a truly good and loyal samurai. While some might have just accepted the death of Asano and walked away, the loyalty of these men, and their need to seek vengeance was greater than any need for self preservation. Since this is a very typical Asian film, it requires that in the end, the men must die or face dishonor. In the film, while many men swore to protect Asano’s good name, after well over a hundred men said they would help, only forty-seven showed up for the event. So there were some samurai in the film that did not show up out of fear, and probably a need for self preservation, but it was Oishi and his men that became legends, and their story still survives today.
If a Western viewer is looking for action in this film, they will be hard pressed to find it. While the film is a film about samurai, it is a very non-violent drama. The film is certainly about the adventures of the forty-seven ronin, not all of those adventures require violence. It is actually a very “true” samurai film, as it shows the ronin in their day-to-day lives which are actually kind of boring, but this is part of their deception. If they had acted in a violent manner from the beginning, their plan would not have work because everyone would know what they were trying to do. To lull the enemy into a sense of false security was a great strategy and it worked perfectly. The only really great action sequence in the film happens in the last twenty minutes19 when they actually put their plan into action.

Gohatto—Justice and Loyalty to One’s Self
Gohatto20 actually means taboo, but as the subject of homosexuality might be taboo for us here in the West, it was not at all a taboo subject for the people of the Tokugawa era, in which Gohatto was set. Right at the moment though, the focus is loyalty and not homosexuality, which will be discussed later. Sozaburo Kano is the son of a wealthy merchant, but he decides to join the Shinsengumi, which Alain Silver describes as a “new group of select [men]”; citizen militia, quasi-unofficial police and vigilantes for the Tokugawa in Kyoto during the bakumatsu.21 Since the Shinsengumi are not technically samurai, they do not serve any lord, but they are pro-Shogunate, meaning that their loyalty is to the Shogun22. Kano, being only eighteen is one of the best candidates for the job, but his love for men and the unwanted attention he gets from the other men sometimes hampers his abilities.
The fact that he is chosen for the Shinsengumi, which was actually an elite squad means that he has to prove himself. The thing holding him back though is the constant speculation about who he’s sleeping with, whether or not he’s ever been with a woman, and basically every other sexual query the leaders of the squad can think of. Kano, while being the youngest and most beautiful is very susceptible to being taken advantage of. So in this film, his greatest loyalty has to be to himself, and there also has to be that loyalty to the Shogun, but he must watch out for number one in the end. In the end of the film he is the only one who can protect and champion for himself. This is because, while Kano is good at what he does, he cannot say no to a superior and keep his place in the Shinsengumi. He is his own greatest protector.
In the end, Gohatto is a film about gay samurai and how Kano solves his relationship issues in the end. This is however, a very taboo subject for Western audiences who may be scared away by the “gay sex” in the film. It is also a very dramatically heavy film, and it relies on the drama to push it forward. While it certainly has an interesting storyline, Western audiences might not appreciate it as much as Eastern audiences might. Even Eastern audiences might find it a little difficult to handle, as there are people in Japan who are still very conservative. This film is intended then for the open minded drama lovers out there. It is what a viewer might consider an arthouse film, or a film made for a certain Western audience.
Gohatto does have one love scene in it between Kano and another man, Tojiro Yuzawa, and there is another implied scene earlier in the film where the viewer knows what is happening behind closed door, but we are not allowed to see it. This is just one of the matches they believe Kano Sozaburo is involved in. They have also seen a man named Hyozo Tashiro sniffing around Kano. Despite the fact that homosexuality was practiced in the late Tokugawa era that Kano lives in, the film makes us wonder if Kano really wants the attention of these two men who are pushing themselves on him.
The first night that Kano sleeps in the same room with Tashiro, Tashiro asks Kano in his sleep, “have you ever killed a man? Have you ever made love?”23 Kano is only eighteen years old, which suggests that he may be a virgin in more than one respect. Tsuneo Watanabe and Jun’ichi Iwata say in the book The love of the samurai : a thousand years of Japanese homosexuality24
the term which designated the object of pederastic love changed from chigo (literally:young child) to wakashu (literally: young man). This corresponds to the change in the age suitable to be loved: the chigo would have been from about ten or eleven to sixteen or seventeen years old; the wakashu was now from about thirteen or fourteen to eighteen or nineteen, sometimes even more than twenty years old. There appeared a homosexuality of a military type comparable to that of the Spartans. This kind of pederasty was called shudo.25
Kano is just about the right age to be somebodies beautiful wakashu, but neither man who is attempting to seduce him really ask him if he wants to be a willing participant. In some areas in the film, you get the idea that he is an unwilling participant in what is happening to him. When he and Tojiro have sex during the film, afterward, Tojiro threatens Kano twice, once with a hand around his throat and another when he says he will “kill”26 anyone who is in their way, but when he first says it, it sounds as if he is saying he will kill Kano, but he says “no, not you”.
While Kano has to be loyal to his comrades, he also has to find a way to protect himself. This is a very complicated situation that could end in his death, so the need to tread carefully is important. Again, he is his own best friend, and he has to try and figure out how to deal with the situation without threatening his place in the Shinsengumi or putting his own life in danger. This is easier said than done, and Kano must find a solution on his own. If he tells someone within the Shinsengumi that he is an unwilling participant in sex with these two men, it will make him look weak in front of his superiors. If he does nothing, he will continue to be the victim, which is equally unacceptable. Finding his way out of this without making it clear what is truly happening is a must.
Kano, being smart young man knows exactly how to fix his problem of having two unwanted suitors. Kill Yuzawa and frame Tashiro for the murder. Thankfully for Kano, everything falls into alignment and he is chosen to execute Tashiro when he’s been duly framed. Tashiro doesn’t realize until they are dueling that he has been set up, and when he does realize, he tries to kill Kano. Kano knows what to do and says “forgive me”.27 Tashiro falls for this, his heart softening, and Kano takes this moment to kill him. In her book The Waves at Genji’s Door: Japan Through Its Cinema28, Joan Mellen says that Kurosawa’s women in film are, “angel on the outside and demon within”.29 Can the same possibly be said for the young wakashu Kano who does not even have to try to get attention? Could he be the victim of those who take advantage, and is merely taking revenge against those who have hurt him? It is hard to say, but in the end, he took care of his problem. Justice has been served because Kano has dealt with his antagonists. He stayed true to himself and his his plan and everything turned out for the best. He came out of it without help and without looking weak. It can therefore be seen as a triumph over the wills of evil in his life.
The love/hate triangle going on in Gohatto might be difficult for some American audiences to understand, as it is an odd and different sort of relationship going on between Kano and the two other men involved. Basically Kano is trapped in two relationships that are being forced on him. While he can’t object to them, they have no idea that they might have to fear him. Kano does not love these men, they love him and look on him as some sort of lovely pet, or something. This was very much the way it was in Japan between samurai and wakashu in the Tokugawa era. Sometimes a young apprentice did not choose to be in a relationship but ended up in one anyway. There is definitely a social pecking order in this case where Kano, the son of a merchant who joined the Shinsengumi at the age of eighteen, is at the mercy of the samurai and higher ranking men within the Shinsengumi. His solution is to set up his enemies and destroy both of them while making himself look like the innocent. In some ways he is, and in some ways he is not. When the audience figures out what has happened, they will judge him and decide whether justice has been done.